AnalysisMoney

Peter Thiel’s Longtime Partner Says AI Is “Absolutely” a Bubble: What Jack Selby Warned and What It Means for Your Money

Jack Selby, Peter Thiel's business partner for 27 years, says the AI boom is a bubble and a correction is "when, not if." Here's what he warned, the warning signs he points to, and how regular investors can prepare.

Current image: Illustration of a large bubble with glowing circuit patterns and a rising chart beginning to crack above a city skyline, representing fears of an AI market bubble

Peter Thiel is trending because one of his closest business partners just called the AI boom a bubble. Jack Selby, managing director at Thiel Capital and Thiel’s partner for 27 years, said anyone who doesn’t believe there’s an AI bubble is “an absolute contrarian,” and that a correction is a question of when, not if.

That’s a striking warning from inside the circle of one of tech’s most influential investors, whose bets include OpenAI, SpaceX and Palantir. If you own index funds or tech stocks, you already have a stake in how this plays out. Here’s what Selby said, why it matters, and what you can do about it.

Who is Peter Thiel?

Peter Thiel is a billionaire tech investor and entrepreneur. He co-founded PayPal and the data analytics company Palantir, and he was an early outside investor in Facebook. Through his funds, he has also invested in AI-related companies including OpenAI, SpaceX and Palantir.

He runs Thiel Capital, his investment firm, where Jack Selby is a managing director. Thiel is also a prominent and often controversial political donor, but this week’s news is about markets, not politics.

Who is Jack Selby?

Selby has known Thiel for 28 years and worked with him for 27 of them. He was one of the first 10 employees at PayPal, part of the early team often called the “PayPal Mafia” because so many went on to found or fund major tech companies.

Today he invests in startups through Thiel Capital and has long argued that great companies can be built outside Silicon Valley.

What did Jack Selby say about the AI bubble?

Selby made his comments in early November, including at the SALT London investment conference. His main points:

  • It’s a bubble. He said high valuations, inflated price multiples and circular financing, where AI companies invest in each other and then buy each other’s products, all point to a bubble.
  • It will correct. He called a correction a matter of when, not if, and warned it could wipe out hundreds of billions of dollars in capital. One report quotes him saying it could burst before the new year.
  • It’s different from the dot-com bubble in one key way. Today’s AI boom requires enormous spending on data centers and chips, and he said many companies rely on storytelling to raise money.
  • AI itself isn’t the problem. He called AI an amazing tool, but said too much pressure is being placed on building trillion-dollar companies.
  • Stop comparing every startup to the giants. He said Anthropic and SpaceX are once-in-a-generation companies that shouldn’t be the yardstick for other startups.

His biggest practical lesson for investors: the price you pay going in matters more than finding the next trillion-dollar winner.

Why does a Thiel partner’s warning matter?

Because it comes from inside the AI boom, not from a skeptic on the sidelines. Thiel and funds connected to him are invested in AI companies, so this isn’t a critic with nothing at stake.

It also fits a pattern in Thiel’s own moves. His hedge fund sold its Nvidia stake back in the third quarter of 2025, well before the latest round of bubble warnings.

What warning signs is Selby pointing to?

Here’s how the signals Selby cites line up with what’s happening in markets, and what each one means for a regular investor:

Warning signWhat’s happeningWhat it means for you
High valuationsAI company prices are far above their current profitsLess room for error if growth slows
Circular financingAI firms invest in each other and buy each other’s productsRevenue can look stronger than real outside demand
Huge infrastructure spendingData centers and chips need massive upfront investmentCompanies must earn it back, or losses follow
Stressed AI infrastructure stocksCoreWeave, Nebius and IREN fell more than 30% in about a monthSome cracks are already showing
Expensive debtSome AI infrastructure debt is yielding 15% to 16%Lenders see real risk
Concentrated venture moneyOnly eight firms raised roughly $70 billion this yearMoney is flowing to a few big AI bets

Is everyone convinced AI is a bubble?

No, and it’s worth hearing the other side. Bulls point out that AI spending is still growing fast. Gartner forecast in May that worldwide AI spending will reach $2.59 trillion in 2026, up 47% from last year. Big tech companies are earning real revenue from AI cloud services, unlike many dot-com startups that had little revenue at all.

Selby himself doesn’t think AI is worthless. Even if there’s a correction, he believes AI lets smaller teams build valuable companies anywhere, not just in Silicon Valley. A bubble can burst while the technology underneath keeps changing the world, as the internet did after 2000.

We dug into how companies are actually spending on AI, and where they’re pulling back, in our look at whether companies are cutting AI spending.

What does an AI bubble mean for your money?

If you own an S&P 500 index fund, you have more AI exposure than you might think, because the index is heavily weighted toward the biggest tech companies. A sharp AI correction would hit your portfolio even if you never bought an AI stock directly.

Here’s a simple way to estimate your risk. Suppose AI-linked stocks fall 40% in a correction:

Share of your portfolio in AI-heavy stocksDrop in those stocksHit to your whole portfolio
10%40%About 4%
30%40%About 12%
50%40%About 20%

The math: multiply the share of your portfolio by the drop. The 40% figure is a hypothetical for illustration, not a forecast.

A few practical steps if Selby’s warning worries you:

  1. Check your concentration. Look at your fund fact sheets or brokerage account to see how much is in big tech and AI names.
  2. Rebalance, don’t panic. If AI stocks have grown into a much bigger share of your portfolio than you planned, trimming back to your target is a disciplined move. Selling everything is a bet on timing, which rarely works.
  3. Keep cash for near-term needs. Money you’ll need in the next few years shouldn’t be in volatile stocks, bubble or not.
  4. Remember the long game. As we covered in Warren Buffett’s guidance for a stock market downturn, steady investors who keep buying through drops tend to come out ahead. A broad, low-cost approach like Buffett’s S&P 500 advice is built to ride out corrections.

My take: Selby’s warning is worth taking seriously, mostly because of who it’s coming from. But “AI is a bubble” and “sell everything now” are very different conclusions. The useful lesson is his own: what you pay matters. Make sure you aren’t overpaying for AI exposure you don’t need, and that your plan can survive a correction if one comes.

This article is for general information and isn’t personal financial advice.

What to Watch Next

  • Nvidia earnings (expected late November 2026): Results from the biggest AI chipmaker are the market’s main test of AI demand.
  • AI infrastructure stocks and debt (ongoing): Watch whether the slide in companies like CoreWeave deepens or recovers.
  • Year-end AI stock offerings (late 2026 to 2027): How new AI listings are priced, and how they trade, will show whether investor appetite is holding up.
  • Selby’s “before the new year” timeline (December 31, 2026): One report says he warned the bubble could burst before year-end. The coming weeks will test that call.

Spotted an error? Contact the editors.